Every December, a quiet imbalance sits in our classrooms. By the end of the year, most students have been told plenty about what they need to fix. Reports have gone home. Reminders have been repeated. Corrections have, let’s be honest, been frequent, and some were delivered on the fifth Friday of a very long term.
How many of those students have heard, specifically, what they did well?
Adam Voigt wrote in his Home Truth “A Deeper Appreciation” about end-of-year gifts for teachers. His point was simple: the presents that touch teachers most are rarely the expensive ones. They’re the ones with time and effort in them, like a hand-drawn poster, a recorded thank-you or a handwritten letter. He reminds us that November is the moment for a school to say, out loud, that it values appreciation more than dollars. You can read his piece here.
I agree with him, and I’d like to turn the lens around. If time and effort are what make appreciation land for us, the same is true for our students.
Specific beats generous
“Great job this term,” is kind, and it’s forgettable. A student can’t do anything with it. What has affect is evidence that an adult noticed something specific.
In RP2.0 we call this an Affective Statement. Say what you were going to say anyway, then add a feelings word. For appreciation, it sounds like this: “I noticed you waited for the new student at the gate. I felt really proud, that you showed care and kindness!”
The only rule is that it’s true. Students can spot a performance from the other side of the oval.
Start with the hardest to appreciate
Every class has a student who has received more corrections than anyone else this year. They are the most likely to walk out the gate in December believing they were the problem.
Finding one true, specific thing to say to them costs you thirty seconds, and it might be the sentence they carry into the holidays. It will feel awkward the first time. Do it anyway.
Encourage students do it for each other
Check-Out Circles are built for this. In Restoring Teaching, Adam describes using a weekly Check-Out Circle to have students turn and talk to the person next to them about something they have appreciated or noticed about someone in class or at school. In the last weeks of term, try a version of it. With the values on the board and the year behind you: “Turn and talk about a time this year you saw someone in this class behave in a way that added value to our class or school or affected you positively.” Then listen.
One note a day
If you can manage it, write a short-handwritten note to one student before each break. For a class of about 25 across the last five weeks of term, that’s one a day. It’s the classroom version of the macaroni poster: small, handmade and worth more because of the effort.
If you teach 150 students, pick one class or one year level.
Language first
This is what we mean when we say RP2.0 starts with Language. What a school says, and how it says it, across the whole staff, shapes everything that follows. Appreciation isn’t an add-on at the end of the year. It’s one of the clearest places to practise the language you’ll want in February.
Keep it simple, true and say it before the bell goes on the last day!